Proper 17 / Ordinary 22 (Aug. 28-Sept. 3)
Texts: Matthew 16:21-28;
Rom 12:9-21; Jer 15:15-21
Sermon Take-Home Notes
Excerpt Page from John Dear
JESUS’ POLITICS, PART 2: REVOLUTIONARY POLITICS OF NONVIOLENCE
The binge-worthy TV shows these days do a good job of leaving you hanging at the end of every episode. You’re tempted to binge because you have to find out what happens next. But just in case you did find the will-power to take a break from watching, you might need the recap they provide at the beginning of the next episode. When I’m binging several episodes, I appreciate the option to skip the recap. But, otherwise, the recap can be very helpful. Have you noticed that the good TV recaps don’t just give you clips of the previous episode but also the relevant retails from other previous episodes that are going to help you watch what’s next?
That’s what I need to do this morning with today’s episode from Matthew’s Gospel. You might remember that last week’s episode is Part 1 to today’s episode. It’s really a two-parter that they split in the middle. But I think it’s helpful to provide more context today than just last week’s episode. In fact, we are about halfway through Matthew’s Gospel, so let’s pretend last week was the season ending cliff-hanger — Jesus takes his disciples on a journey to a place charged with political relevance to ask them the political question, “Who do you say that I am?” Peter gets it right. He’s the long-awaited Messiah, the one Yahweh has sent to free their people from centuries of political oppression in other people’s empires. That’s the end of Season One. We’re ready to see the drama of Jesus’ campaign as Messiah unfold in Season Two.
Except we need a recap of Season One. (I don’t have video clips but I invite you to follow along in today’s Sermon Notes):
• First comes the Birth story: there is a hope for a new king for all peoples, signified by the visit from the far east by three Magi — contrasted with the horrifying brutality of Rome’s present puppet-king, Herod, who kills all the boys of Bethlehem to try to head-off this new king that isn’t one of his sons.
• Next, we jump to Jesus as an adult. He is baptized by his cousin John, with God’s spirit descending on him like a dove and a voice signaling God’s favor, “You are my beloved son.”
• Immediately, the spirit strangely pushes Jesus out into the wilderness for a vision quest, a month of prayer that ends with the temptation from Satan to rule like he does over all the kingdoms of the earth.
• Instead of taking Satan up on his offer, Jesus moves to Galilee, where he begins his own campaign proclaiming the coming of God’s kingdom into the world, which will require repentance, a deep change of mind and heart to be open to God’s very different reign.
• Jesus’ major address, the Sermon on the Mount, introduces themes:
• Beatitudes for the marginalized people of human reigns
• Nonviolence – turning the other cheek, loving one’s enemies
• Non-anxious presence: live in trust not fear, trusting in God’s protection and provision, seeing abundance not scarcity
• Non judgmentalism: don’t remove the speck in a neighbor’s eye, neglecting the log in your own; doing unto others what you would want done unto you (i.e., kindness to all)
• In short, revolutionary values quite the opposite of empires
• Jesus gathers disciples, his campaign team, and begins to live out God’s reign by healing all who come to him, casting out the demons of violent empire.
• What Jesus is saying and doing is so different that even his cousin John (who’s in prison) is confused; he sends his followers to ask Jesus what he’s about. Jesus answers with the Jubilee texts of the prophet Isaiah, about God’s reign bring healing and liberation to all — but finishing with this amazing distinction: “Departing the days of John the Baptist until now: the kingdom of heaven chooses to suffer violence, and the violent take it by force” (Matt 11:12). In short, Jesus even differs from his cousin by choosing a different response to imperial violence: to suffer it rather than return it.
• Crazy! And so Jesus begins to receive blow-back and resistance, especially from other leaders like the Pharisees. Many others simply do not understand and just come for the healing benefits.
• Jesus responds to the resistance and misunderstanding by beginning to teach in parables with layered meaning. First, with narrated stores like the Parable of the Sower and the other parables of Matthew 13
• But then also in acted-out parables in Matthew 14-16 that ring out the themes of the Sermon on the Mount:
• Miraculous feedings that ‘speak of’ abundance not scarcity
• Walking on water — water a symbol of chaotic violence — as maintaining a non-anxious presence in the face of danger
• Letting a Canaanite woman best him in a ‘war of words’ to teach his disciples non-judgmentalism and mercy to even foreigners
• Bringing us to Caesarea Philippi, for a political parable that will ring out the theme of . . . what?! Jesus is the promised Messiah. What will that mean? That’s where Season One dramatically ends.
Bringing us to today’s episode, still in Caesarea Philippi. After this recap, what comes next should come as no surprise to the audience. Jesus will ring out the theme of nonviolence. The coming of God’s reign will choose to suffer imperial violence but never return it. The days of trying to stop violence with violence have taken a dramatic turn.
This shouldn’t shock the audience, but it shocks the disciples. They’re not sure they signed up for this kind of messianic campaign. Again, Peter is their spokesperson. “God forbid it,” he says. “We will never let this happen!” They’re apparently ready for the fight. But Jesus stops Peter in his tracks with a seemingly harsh counter-rebuke, “Follow behind me, Satan!” Peter, of course, doesn’t know what Jesus experienced in his temptations in the wilderness. But to us, the audience, we know that Jesus has come to take charge and lead the world into a completely different style of reigning than Satan. He has come to end the madness of the scapegoating violence of empires by suffering the violence in faith that God’s power of love and life is stronger that the forces that lead to death. Since Satan metaphorically has ruled all human empires up to this point, it seems like madness. It is counter to all the gods who have propped up empire even to this day.
The God of Jesus is so completely different, in fact, that, did you know the early Christians were considered as atheists in the Roman Empire? Their God was so different from the Roman gods that most people of that time couldn’t recognize Jesus’ God as god at all. When the early Christians were martyred, it was often to cries of, “Kill the atheists!” But slowly over those first few centuries, more people came to understand that this difference was in fact healing and liberating. Even in the midst of a brutal empire, they could begin to live in communities of care and love, finding their lives flourishing in ways that made a difference.
But we’ve talked about what happened in the fourth century. In a brilliant move, the Emperor Constantine made Christianity the imperial religion and things began to change. It hasn’t all been for the worse. Seeds of Christian mercy and love have continued to grow and make a difference in people’s lives. But I submit to you that the crucial aspect of Jesus’ mission had all but disappeared. I’m talking about the different, revolutionary response to imperial violence; namely, that we are called to follow behind Jesus in choosing to suffer that violence and never return it. We can learn to walk on the water of chaotic violence with the same assurance of God’s ultimate power of love and life. In another irony of history, a Hindu man, Mahatma Gandhi, has helped revive this center of Jesus’ teaching and life.
Let me end with a question of sorts. The Roman Empire of the first century experienced the early Christians as atheists because their God was so alien to them. A God who suffered violence rather than stand in authority over all the violence, wielding it against enemies. But since Gandhi revived this nonviolent God, and the so-called Christian nations have continued to trust in a sacred violence to wield against enemies, have the tables turned to some extent? Is this one of the reasons that many people have left the church? In a democratic society, they are tired of all the warring and killing and want to live by a different set of values centered in love. So is this another way in which getting our message right can help bring some people back to church? To the extent that churches participate in today’s nonviolent movements against injustice, is this something inviting to some who have left? And, in any case, the most important question should always be: what should we be doing in today’s world to be more fully faithful to the Gospel of Jesus Christ? Amen
Paul J. Nuechterlein
Bethania Lutheran Church,
Racine, WI, August 30, 2026
Sermon Take-Home Notes
Excerpt Page from John Dear
